Posted on Jun 16th, 2007
by
Nathan
Vienna, June 16, 2007
Kurt Waldheim--former Secretary General of the United Nations, former President of Austria, former First Lieutenant in the German Wehrmacht--died two days ago. His picture is in all the newspapers, and the question of his character has come up again. Today his two-page political testament was published in the papers. "Ich bitte um Versöhnung," he wrote shortly before he died. "To all those who critically confronted me, I send my greeting, and ask them to think about their motives again, and--if possible--to grant me a late reconciliation."
Today there was an event in Kirchstetten, Austria, to commemorate the 100th anniversary of the birth of W.H. Auden, the British/American poet who summered there from 1958 until his death in Vienna in 1973. There were some talks about Auden, and some lunch, and then we all went to Auden's old house, whose upstairs study is preserved as a mini-museum. Many of the poet's things are still there, including books, furniture, and slippers. In Auden's study, the British poet Glyn Maxwell read a number of Auden's poems very movingly.
Before and after Maxwell's reading, I spoke with a local man who turned out to have been close to Kurt Waldheim during Waldheim's tenure as Secretary General of the United Nations in New York. I offered my condolences. I asked him whether Waldheim had been unjustly attacked for having covered up his past, and he said yes, absolutely. "Let's be honest: the United States government is controlled by Jews," he said, adding, "And the World Jewish Congress raised millions of dollars in funding by attacking Waldheim."
He further noted that his own father had been in the Wehrmacht, and told him that if anyone questioned what was happening--i.e., the war effort--they and their family would be killed. He said that at the UN, Waldheim was a bridge-builder, a man skilled at negotiation, a tireless negotiator, a worker for peace.
I said, "I'm half-Jewish and I completely accept that individuals in Waldheim's generation could not go against the Nazi machine without committing suicide themselves. But I want the truth to come out. I don't want people hiding what they did. I don't think badly of people who had the bad luck to be swept up in something terrible when they were young."
He said, "People in Waldheim's position preferred to be silent for fear of being attacked."
I said, "Maybe we can begin more sensible dialogues now. I don't want to attack people. We just want to know what happened to our families."
We parted. Questions hung in the air: Whose story is this? How much information needs to come out? On what terms can reconciliation happen?
The image I have of Waldheim today is of someone very human, caught up in something he didn't understand, later regretful about it, though not as regretful as his critics would have him be. One of the men Waldheim served under was executed for war crimes in 1946. So at what point should Waldheim himself have felt comfortable telling the world everything?
He certainly seems to have known what was going on, but he seems not to have been personally responsible in any criminal sense for atrocities. The Nazi hunter Simon Wiesenthal publically defended Waldheim along these lines. Misleading people about one's past is not in itself a crime. It seems natural, though less than ideal, that people who were still furious at the Nazis would have wanted to criticize him.
Today the Holocaust is as much a nightmare for the Austrians and the Germans as it is for the Jews. One of my Austrian students told me tearfully once of the day he learned of the Holocaust at the age of nine when he walked in on his mother watching a documentary on TV and she explained to him the bulldozers pushing emaciated human corpses.
Former Wehrmacht soldiers have either remained convinced of the rightness of the Nazi cause--a small minority--or, more commonly, refused to talk about it. Or both. One of my current students tried to interview his grandfather about the war for a school project, and his grandfather flatly refused to talk about it. The impression I got was of a concrete container full of toxic chemical waste that wants to be buried just like it is so the poison won't leak out. It's one response, heroic in its way.
I'll finish this post about reconciliation with some lines from Auden's elegy for the Irish poet W.B. Yeats, who died at the beginning of 1939 as the Second World War was about to break out. Whatever side of whatever nightmare one is on, Auden's challenge--for action that is personal, psychological and emotional, even spiritual in the best sense--is worth taking seriously: Make a vinyard of a curse.
Follow, poet, follow right
To the bottom of the night,
With your unconstraining voice
Still persuade us to rejoice.
With the farming of a verse
Make a vineyard of the curse,
Sing of human unsuccess
In a rapture of distress.
In the deserts of the heart
Let the healing fountains start,
In the prison of his days
Teach the free man how to praise.
Access: Public
Print
views (276)